News

Personalization Matters: How Tailored Voluntary Benefits Boost Employee Engagement

Written by Peter E Marcia | Jul 22, 2025 2:30:38 PM

The workplace has become more diverse and dynamic than ever, with employees spanning multiple generations, life stages, and unique personal circumstances. As a result, they expect their employers to meet their individual needs. For benefits managers, this means personalization is key—especially when it comes to voluntary benefits. Employers who embrace this challenge see real rewards, including improved employee engagement, stronger trust, and higher adoption rates for benefits programs.

According to a recent study by MetLife, 72% of employees said that having a wider choice of benefits would increase their loyalty to their employer. This highlights how offering personalized benefits not only meets diverse employee needs but also strengthens the overall employer-employee relationship.

Personalized voluntary benefits aren’t just a trendy offering—they’re a proven way to enhance your team’s experiences and make them feel valued. Here’s how tailored solutions can transform employee engagement in your organization.

The Rise of Personalized Voluntary Benefits

Gone are the days of one-size-fits-all benefits plans. Historically, businesses kept voluntary benefits limited and generic, assuming blanket offerings would satisfy most of the workforce. But with today’s diverse and multigenerational teams, that approach is no longer effective.

      • Gen Z employees - may prioritize student loan repayment or wellness programs
  • Millennials often value benefits like mental health services and financial planning tools.
  • Gen X staff might look for resources like caregiving assistance and supplemental health coverage.
  • Boomers nearing retirement could prioritize long-term care planning and estate guidance 

This variety in employee demographics makes personalization essential. When employees see that their benefits package acknowledges and addresses their specific needs, they are far more likely to engage.

Why Personalized Benefits Drive Engagement

According to MetLife’s 2025 Employee Benefits Trends Study, personalized benefits improve engagement in two significant ways:

  1. Relevance Drives Engagement: Employees are far more likely to participate in benefits that align with their individual needs and priorities. For instance, offering tailored perks like student loan assistance or professional development opportunities to new hires shows that the company recognizes and values what matters most to them.
  2. Trust and Care Foster Loyalty: Employees who trust their employer and feel genuinely cared for are three times more likely to report higher overall well-being. Personalized benefits not only reflect this care but also strengthen trust, cultivating long-term loyalty and commitment.

Personalized recommendations cut through the noise in overwhelming traditional benefits models. Smart tools, such as AI technology, now enable companies to guide employees toward tailored solutions, removing decision fatigue and making benefits more approachable. This leads to better utilization of benefits, creating a win-win situation for both employees and employers. Additionally, personalized benefits show that the company values and cares about their employees as individuals, rather than just a number in the system.

Furthermore, personalized benefits go beyond just selecting the right healthcare plan or retirement savings option. They can also include wellness programs, professional development opportunities, and financial wellness initiatives such as budgeting tools or retirement planning, all tailored to each employee's specific needs and interests. By understanding their employees' unique situations and desires, companies can create a more inclusive and supportive workplace culture.

The result? Employees feel valued and supported by their employers, leading to increased job satisfaction and motivation - which ultimately translates into higher productivity and better business outcomes. 

Solutions in Action

Personalization isn’t just about offering more—it’s about offering smarter and the proof is in the data. Employees who engage with their benefits are proven to experience higher productivity and health outcomes. For instance (MetLife):

                • Employees who feel satisfied with their benefits program are 70% more likely to feel loyal to their employer
                • Gen Z employees offered financial planning resources are 40% more likely to feel financially healthy, signaling the importance of targeted programs.
                • HR experts report that personalized benefits can reduce turnover by up to 18%, significantly cutting talent management costs.

These statistics highlight just how central tailored benefits are to fostering workplace satisfaction and trust. As HR professionals and benefits managers, it's our responsibility to continuously evaluate and adjust benefits offerings to meet the evolving needs of our employees. In today's competitive job market, employers who prioritize personalized benefits will not only attract top talent, but also retain skilled and engaged employees.

How to Bring Personalization into Your Benefits Strategy

Now comes the big question—how do you implement personalization at scale for your organization? Here’s a clear path forward.

1. Expand Your Menu - A wider menu allows employees to choose options that align closely with their priorities. Include creative options like:

                              • Pet insurance
                              • Identity theft protection
                              • Critical illness
                              • Legal insurance
                              • Financial coaching
                              • Student loan repayment assistance
                              • Caregiving support

2. Leverage AI Technology - Harness digital platforms and AI-powered tools to analyze employee data, ensuring personalized recommendations. AI can help identify patterns and trends in employee benefits usage, allowing HR teams to make informed decisions on benefit offerings. With the right technology, employers can also effectively communicate benefit updates and changes in a timely manner through various channels such as emails, mobile apps, or chatbots.

AI technology can play a crucial role in predicting future healthcare costs and identifying potential gaps in coverage. This predictive analysis allows employers to proactively address any issues with their current benefits plan and make necessary adjustments to ensure comprehensive coverage for employees.

3. Segment Employee Communications - Everyone communicates differently. Consider targeted outreach for different groups (e.g., millennials, working parents, remote employees) to highlight the benefits most relevant to them. This tailored messaging increases awareness while maintaining an approachable tone.

4. Measure Performance and Adjust - Collect data on enrollment rates and feedback to identify gaps and continuously evolve your strategy. This ensures your offerings remain aligned with the changing needs of your workforce.

Building Trust Through Personalization

At its core, personalized voluntary benefits show employees they’re more than just a number—they’re individuals whose well-being matters. This cultivates employee trust and strengthens relationships, creating a workplace culture where engagement and loyalty thrive.

According to industry findings from Gallup, employees who feel seen and cared for are not only happier—they’re also more productive, healthy, and invested in their roles. That’s where personalized benefits come in, offering a tangible way to foster those feelings and drive meaningful results for both employees and organizations.

Personalization in voluntary benefits isn’t just an HR buzzword—it’s a proven strategy to boost engagement, reduce turnover, and build a workplace culture rooted in trust and care. As the workforce evolves, so should your benefits strategy.

If your organization is ready to create a more dynamic and engaging benefits experience, don’t leave it up to guesswork. Commit to a people-first approach by tailoring voluntary benefits to meet the unique needs of your team. Start making your offerings work smarter—not harder.